Sunday 20 August 2023

Two Lonely Churches

The county of Suffolk, like much of East Anglia, is mostly given over to arable farming, often by very large estates. But cast adrift on this sea of barley and wheat, sugar beet and potatoes, one occasionally finds tiny churches, all alone and at a distance from their villages. Lets visit two of them, both isolated through history but otherwise different in every way.



Hemingstone church stands on a small mound overlooking fertile fields, midway between the tiny village and the ancient pile of its Hall. It's the sort of setting that feels that it might be a religious meeting place of the pre-Christian era. Today it has just a farm for a neighbour.



At first glance it looks to be a typical village church, but then you notice that it has two porches standing side by side on its north wall. What's all that about? I wonder.



After I've pushed and tugged at the porch door to no avail - and my brother has then managed to open it with no problem - we discover a huge set of blacksmith's bellows standing in the corner.



Inside it's somewhat untidy in a rustic sort of way with lots of memorial plaques on the wall, commemorating many generations of the wealthy of the parish.
 


There's a very beautiful font said to date from the fourteenth century. Behind it is a painting of St Gregory (to whom the church is dedicated) and above that the royal coat of arms. Lets have a closer look at that. One thing I've learned is to always photograph these, there are often little mistakes or discrepancies.



WR at the top means it dates from the reign of William III, usually known as William of Orange, presumably after the death of his wife, Mary. So it probably dates from between 1694 and 1702. The detail of the coat of arms in the centre should confirm this. But...that's NOT the correct coat of arms for William....or indeed anyone else. The first quarter (top left) should be the arms of England, but the French arms have been put in their place, with the English arms relegated to the fourth quarter. Odd....can it just be a mistake?



Nearby is the memorial to those who gave their lives (or were robbed of their lives) in the First World War. It's terrible to think that four young lives were lost, even in a quiet hamlet like this.



This must be the blocked south door with one of a series of now largely indecipherable painted wall-signs above it. I like the weathered look of the walls.



I also liked the aged look of the rather battered organ, which doesn't seem to fit the building in any way at all - apart from being rustic and functional. And standing opposite it is the grand, if slightly rough-hewn memorial to William Cantrell, once of Hemingstone Hall.



Presumably it would have been paid for by his son and heir, Ralph, who was a very interesting character. It was during his time that the whole village was up before the church authorities for irregularities in their way of worship. At that time the Church of England laid down very strict rules about who must attend church (EVERYBODY) and who could be a Catholic (NO ONE). These rules were obeyed in most places, but in remote backwaters like this the gentry were used to doing exactly what they wanted...and Ralph was a Catholic.



Now to that second porch. Ralph, as the Lord of the Manor, had to pay for the fabric of the village church and also had to be seen to attend regularly. To solve part of his problem he had a second porch built; the villagers would enter through one and he and his family through the other. But this was not just an example of class snobbery. For while one porch led into the church the other didn't and here the Cantrells would quietly celebrate their Catholic mass while the regular service took place in the main church. If you scroll back to the picture of William Cantrell's monument you'll see there is a tiny window to the right. With this open, Ralph was technically attending the service!



That royal coat of arms must have been put there in Ralph's time too, which was also during the Nine Years War, when the Protestant William III was up against France, which was of course Catholic. Was Ralph instructed by the church that he must have the royal arms on display in the church, as was then a requirement, and did he respond by having these altered arms installed as an insult to the king he strongly opposed? Brave, if reckless.


*******

You just never know what history (and mysteries) you might encounter deep in the countryside. And now we'll move on to a very different small and isolated church, not too far away.



All Saints at Crowfield also stands well away from its village with just farms for company. In this case it was the village that slowly migrated down towards the old Roman road of Stane Street, leaving just the church and the manor house behind. As you walk down the grassy path towards the church you can still see the moat of the old manor house - even the manor house eventually moved away!



All Saints looks as though it's barely tethered to the real world at all and might at any moment float off into some kind of ethereal never-never-land. That half-timbered chancel must make it one of the prettiest little churches in the country. Shall we lift the latch on the gate?



Oh wow! Surely it won't be open, or will be less enchanting inside.



There's a light shining through the coloured glass!



The inside is just as perfect and shows just how well the Victorians could restore a church if they really tried. The work was carried out from 1862 and was paid for by Lady Anne Middleton in memory of her husband, Sir William Fowle Fowle Middleton. Sir William is also remembered by a plaque on the wall which was placed there by his tenants who recall "his liberal benevolence and sympathy for the poor, the aged and the sick, his care in educating the young...and providing constantly remunerative employment for the labouring and strong".



The bench-ends are each carved with a different design.



The carving was done by two of the finest wood-carvers of that time, Mr James Wormald and Mr William Polly. Their work must be in many churches across East Anglia, though often they were considered as artisans rather than artists and their names go unrecorded.



The stained glass is from the same era and is by the firm Ward & Hughes of London.



The royal coat of arms is unusual in that it is in stained glass too - no mistakes, deliberate or otherwise, in this case, as far as I can tell!



Angels look down from the roof.



You often see boards bearing The Lord's Prayer in our churches, but this one is ornately painted on metal. Lady Anne Middleton was an artist herself and I can't help thinking that her tastes must be reflected in this jewel-like building. 



I love all these homely details. One of the windowsills even displays a model of the church....



If you're ever down this way drop in and visit these lonely little churches - they seem happy to receive callers.


Take care.


30 comments:

  1. All Saints Crowfield is a favourite of mine - especially as they have a flower festival and a huge second hand book stall every year.
    Hemingstone is the opposite. Of all the Suffolk Churches I've visited - over 80 now - it is the only one that felt odd and uncomfortable inside. I looked round and took photos and then got out ASAP!

    ReplyDelete
  2. How wonderful that they were unlocked. Most churches here are now locked during the daytime when no services are going on to prevent vandalism etc.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What a wonderful look at the interiors of these old churches. Some of our churches are opened during the day and locked in the early evening.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Lo lógico que las iglesias se encuentre en los pueblos y ciudades, a no ser que pertenezca a algún monasterio, en donde lo habiten una comunidad de frailes.
    Un abrazo

    ReplyDelete
  5. The second church is very beautiful and well-restored. The first church has lots of interesting history. Thanks for sharing your photos and story.

    ReplyDelete
  6. "those who gave their lives"--that comment always troubles me, suggesting as it does a noble willingness to die in battle. Here in the USA we don't have ancient buildings, but older churches have a sense of long occupancy that is far more welcoming than their modern counter parts. Thank you for taking us there.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The carving on the bench end is beautiful. Such detail! And all different! Incredible!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you for sharing the beauty and some of the history of these gems.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Amazing history!! I was interested in reading about William of Orange as in my town of Newton Abbot, next to the clock tower, marks the spot where the first declaration of William III, Prince of Orange, was read in 1688. He stayed overnight in Newton Abbot as he travelled to London from Brixham to assume the English throne.

    What a strange thing re the coat of arms!! Would be interesting to delve into that further!! Sal

    ReplyDelete
  10. What little gems. And what contortions people used to do (still do I suppose) to get round the 'rules'. I really enjoyed reading Ralph's story.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Two wonderful churches and fascinating to read about the Royal Coat of Arms and the reason for two porches. You have found out some amazing history in that first church. Love the half timbered chancel at All Saints and that wonderful door :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. How I loved this. I just can't imagine. What changes have happened.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Beautiful! I could look at and read about places like these all day!!

    ReplyDelete
  14. I hope someone is looking after these churches as they hold much history.

    ReplyDelete
  15. You have an excellent knowledge of Royal Coat of Arms to be able to spot the mistakes. The second church is a real beauty.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hemingstone is fascinating. The coat of arms is probably intentional...what minion sent by the authorities would notice at a glance, the difference?
    The half obscured inscription is Genesis XXVIII.v.17th.
    "How dreadful is this place this is (?) the other- but ye House of God, and this is ye gate if Heaven."
    So sad that the way that one worshipped was laid down strictly...and all wanting to worship the same god anyway...(as do Jews and Muslims for that matter, all being the Abrahamic faiths..but that is another thread of discussion!!)
    The work in the construction of both churches is well worth seeing.

    But just think how the population has been sucked out of the country to the town...and is being further sucked from thence to cities...

    ReplyDelete
  17. A grand tour from a fine historian. You reveal details the average visitor would never detect and I would wager that many of the parishioners have no idea of the history of these churches. I noted your comment about soldiers being robbed of their lives - so true.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Both are charming in their own ways. Thanks for the history too.

    ReplyDelete
  19. All Saints at Crowfield does have an equal in St. Mary's at Mundon, Essex it is also half timbered. What a pair of quietly beautiful churches, lying along old forgotten. lanes. https://northstoke.blogspot.com/2022/06/churches-stmary-mundon.html

    ReplyDelete
  20. I love that you dig up the stories of the places you visit. Ralph's story made me laugh out loud, but quite honestly, he was a very admirable figure, wasn't he? The second church ? I cannot get over the fact that those pew ends haven't been broken off in all these years! The most wonderful thing about visiting these old churches is that as soon as you step inside, it feels different somehow. As if the reverences of generations have somehow settled onto everything like a holy dust.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Hi John - how fascinating to see these two churches ... I noted Sue in Suffolk's comment - if I ever get up - I'll remember that. Your knowledge of heraldry is pretty impressive ... I've never got to grips with it ... beautiful area - thanks for sharing - cheers Hilary

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. To be honest, Hilary, I can never get my head around the technicalities of heraldry either - that's why I always take a photo then investigate it when I get home.

      Delete
  22. All Saints is truly a little gem of a church. Thank you for the tour. I could spend some time in there, just absorbing the peace of the place.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The last one is my favourite. Tde details are incredible!

    ReplyDelete
  24. My husband and I both enjoyed this post. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  25. Further thoughts... didn't the words dread and dreadful have different meanings in the past?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've always taken it to mean "inspiring awe" in this context - a meaning which Rastafarians still attach to it, I believe.

      Delete
  26. These are churches with a life and soul .

    ReplyDelete
  27. That carving is amazing. So detailed. I would have loved to watch the "artisans" at work. Thank you for your always interesting photos.

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for taking the time to comment. I'll try to answer any questions via a comment or e-mail within the next day or two (no hard questions, please!).