Wednesday 13 March 2019

The Trees They Do Grow High

Last Friday evening I trudged through the drizzle to an event in a neighbouring village. It was arranged by "Waterlight", a project which is documenting our little chalk stream, the River Mel, through film, photography, poetry and prose - and, last Friday, in music too. I'm going to tell you a little of what I learned there (full links and references at the end), and some things I've found out since, all illustrated with some of my own (suitably enhanced) photos.



The house pictured above is on one of my regular walks; I've passed by for years without photographing it or knowing anything about it. But now I know that in the summers of 1906, 1907 and 1908 the composer Ralph Vaughan Williams and his wife took their holidays here. 



While he was here he cycled or took the train to the surrounding villages, where he collected folk songs from farm workers as they gathered in the pubs in the evenings. At that time there was a small but dedicated band of folk song enthusiasts who were determined to keep these old rural traditions alive despite the increasing urbanisation of the country.



As far as is known he only ever collected one song in my home village and that was a song which turns up all over the place, always with very similar words but with slightly different tunes. The title is (usually) "The Trees They Do Grow High" and there are many modern recordings of the song, most famously by Joan Baez and the British folk group Pentangle. The song is said to be based on a true story of a arranged child marriage which took place in the seventeenth century. 




The singer from Meldreth was a man called Ginger Clayton. Vaughan Williams had previously heard the song sung by a Mr Penfold in Sussex in 1904 and had even gone back in 1907 and made a wax cylinder recording of it. In the same year he also ventured to Herefordshire where he heard another variant of the song.



Vaughan Williams was of course mainly interested in the music rather than the words of a song as he attempted to absorb and incorporate elements of the tunes he collected into his own, very English, compositions. You can, should you so desire, view the original manuscripts of his attempts to note down these songs, as they are available online. It may be a mark of his esteem for "The Trees They Do Go High" that he noted down both music and words for this song.



I regret that I don't read music - I have enough trouble with Vaughan Williams's scribbled hand-writing - but I can see enough to realise that his informant must have been an interesting, if undisciplined, singer; the time signature changes between 2/4, 6/8 and 3/4, and he's jotted down the tune for two verses, so presumably the tune had some variations too.



At the end of one of his manuscripts of Ginger Clayton's song a note has been added which looks as though it says "The note values are approximate - the song was sung very freely". And intriguingly it also says "This version has been collected from a phonography record"; so does this mean that there was once a wax cylinder of our local singer?



We don't know what, if anything, Vaughan Williams intended to do with the song, though because he collected several versions and seems interested in the lyric of the song he may well have intended to arrange the song with piano accompaniment. The tune does crop up in the 3rd movement  of his ‘English Folk Songs: suite for military band’, 1923. 



The event I attended last Friday included "our" song and others which Vaughan Williams collected on his sojourn in Cambridgeshire, performed brilliantly by Penni Mclaren Walker and Bryan Causton. If you want to hear a version of the song you can click on any of these below:

Joan Baez sings "The Trees They Do Grow High" from her LP "Joan Baez - Vol 2"
or Pentangle's version from their "Sweet Child" album
for my money the best version is by Martin Carthy on his influential debut recording.
or here's Benjamin Britten's arrangement of the song

if you're really keen you can listen to the wax cylinder version recorded by Vaughan Williams in Sussex in 1907. The singer is Mr Penfold, landlord of the village pub.



My sources:
Waterlight - the project to document the River Mel. Especially the blogpost "Vaughan Williams in Meldreth".
And she must have consulted, among other things, The Vaughan Williams Memorial Library online site.


Take care.





15 comments:

  1. While I listen to Joan singing, I realize I haven't listened, really listened to it before. It is certainly sweet. Thanks for the information on Vaughan Williams...it's so fun to find out what famous people did in sites that are preserved for historic purposes.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have herd of Vaughan Williams and never realised he went around recording music like that. Much as I admire people who record or old folk songs It's not somthing that floats my boaat. I have alway prefered Hard Rock and some of the more modernt techno music

    ReplyDelete
  3. Love the Baez version. That pure, clear voice!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Interesting to hear Vaughan Williams on the wax cylinder version. It's amazing it was made in 1907 and available to listen to in 2019.

    ReplyDelete
  5. To know the history of a song and then hear it performed by such a pure voice? Wow. That is amazing.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Sounds a fun and interesting evening. I often find such events I'd love to learn about but being so deaf means I miss so much and tend not to bother going. Thank God there are still people who are passionate about the minutiae, art and beauty in life and want to preserve them for other's enjoyment. (And I include you in that.)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Fascinating, great the wax cylinder version still exists and that we can hear it. Your lovely black and white photos set the right mood for the song too:)

    ReplyDelete
  8. The Joan Baez version was my fav John although the wax cylinder version was quite astounding! Love the way you have shown your images to capture the mood of the event ✨

    ReplyDelete
  9. I was interested in the Martin Carthy version. I went to a concert of his in Portsmouth many years ago, and then spent some time chatting to him at the railway station as he waited for his train to London and I waited for the train to Southampton.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Martin Carthy MBE is still active as a folk singer today.

      Delete
  10. I remember Joan Baez singing this song but i hadn’t heard it for many years. Had to go to Yugube and take a listen. Beautiful photos in black and white.

    ReplyDelete
  11. A delightful and fascinating piece of history here for sure, John. Thank you for sharing and for visiting my blog - I always enjoy your humour. Happy weekend

    ReplyDelete
  12. Sorry, but I accidentally deleted a comment by Spare Parts And Pics in which he said that it reminded him of the way that blues songs had been collected in the deep south of the USA.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was trying to reply "Yes, indeed. And some of these early collectors of English folk songs, particularly Cecil Sharp, collected songs in the Appalachians. In the mid twentieth century one of our most respected singers, Shirley Collins, travelled with Alan Lomax in the South collecting music from singers like Mississippi Fred McDowell."

      Delete
  13. as always, very interesting. Will listen to the song later. Love what you did with the photographs.

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for taking the time to comment. I'll try to answer any questions via a comment or e-mail within the next day or two (no hard questions, please!).